The Secret of the Black Rose
Read the story: okuriko.com/read-story/the-secret-of-the-black-rose/
Answer the questions after reading the story. The questions are about the opening part that everyone reads, whatever they choose.
1. Reading Comprehension (5W1H)
-
1. Who? Who passes the bottom of the garden on a tour boat and calls out to Ben?
-
2. What? What does Ben see when the first bud opens on Monday morning?
-
3. Where? Where did Cassie plant the cutting she took from the garden?
-
4. When? When is Cassie coming?
-
5. Why? Why have Granny Zelda and Cassie stopped speaking?
-
6. How? How does Granny Zelda get the water that Ben carries to the rosebushes?
2. Vocabulary Matching
Match each word with its meaning. Write the letter of the meaning in the box next to the word.
- 1. cutting
- 2. bud
- 3. clippers
- 4. deck
- 5. bow
- 6. awning
- a) A flower before it has opened, with its petals still wrapped up tight.
- b) A piece cut from a plant's stem that can be planted to grow a whole new plant.
- c) A sheet of cloth stretched out over a shop front like a small roof.
- d) Small, strong garden scissors for cutting stems and twigs.
- e) The flat floor on top of a boat where people stand and walk.
- f) The front end of a boat (it rhymes with "cow").
3. Think and Write
-
• At the first choice, did you send Ben down to the dock to look at Uncle Ken's flowerpot, or have him call Cassie? Why did you pick that path?
-
• Ben is caught between two people he loves who aren't speaking to each other. Have you ever been stuck between two friends or relatives who had fallen out? What did you do, and how did it feel?
-
• When two people both say "I'm right", how can you find out what really happened? Would you look for evidence, listen to both sides, or do both?
-
• Have you ever seen two plants or animals of the same kind that looked different from each other? How would you go about finding out why?
Activity
With a grown-up's help, snip a 10 cm (4 inch) piece from a mint or basil stem, pull off the lower leaves, stand it in a glass of water and draw its roots in a notebook every day for two weeks. Then talk about how Granny Zelda's rose could travel all the way to Istanbul as a single cutting.
In this story, children join Ben in Halfeti as he chases the secret of the black rose, comparing rosebushes, asking questions and holding on to small clues. Alongside the plant puzzle, it takes seriously the hurt between a grandmother and a granddaughter who have stopped speaking. Readers' choices decide which clue Ben follows and who he talks to first.
Learning goals
- Learns about Halfeti's famous black rose and how a new rosebush can be grown from a single cutting.
- Practices putting two similar things side by side and keeping track of the differences to answer a question.
- Learns why it helps to look for evidence before deciding who is right in an argument.
- Thinks about how someone caught between two people who have fallen out can help while caring about both of their feelings.
Curriculum links: Science, Life skills, Social studies. Values: Curiosity, Family, Empathy.
Answer Key
- 1. Their neighbor Uncle Ken, who takes tourists out on the river.
- 2. A rose with petals as soft as velvet and a color that is almost black.
- 3. Outside her flower shop in Istanbul.
- 4. On Saturday, and Ben wants to find out the rose's secret by then.
- 5. When Cassie's rose bloomed bright red in Istanbul, she said on the phone that Granny Zelda had given her the wrong cutting.
- 6. She goes down to the bottom of the stone steps, fills the big bucket from the river and pours it into Ben's little bucket.
Vocabulary matching: 1-b, 2-a, 3-d, 4-e, 5-f, 6-c
Fact Box
- Is Halfeti's black rose really black?
- Not quite. The Halfeti black rose, registered in 2021 as a geographical indication by the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office, is a fragrant rose variety called Louis XIV, and its most distinctive feature is a very dark, almost black red. Its petals have a white line down the middle, and the color gets lighter as the flower opens and ages. (Source: Turkish Patent and Trademark Office)
- How are Halfeti black roses grown?
- From cuttings. At pruning time, between late autumn and the end of winter, growers cut pieces of stem with one to three buds from healthy plants, plant them in prepared soil and water them straight away. (Source: Turkish Patent and Trademark Office)
- Why is the old town of Halfeti partly under water?
- The reservoir behind the Birecik Dam on the Euphrates submerged most of the surrounding villages and part of the old town, so the town was moved to the village of Karaotlak. Today visitors take boat trips on the river and ferries to the ruins of the nearby Rumkale fortress. (Source: Wikipedia)
- Where does the Euphrates River begin and end?
- The Euphrates, called the Fırat in Turkish, begins in eastern Turkey, where the Karasu and Murat rivers meet, and flows through Turkey, Syria and Iraq. In Iraq it joins the Tigris to form the Shatt al-Arab, which empties into the Persian Gulf. At about 2,800 km (roughly 1,700 miles), it is the longest river in Western Asia. (Source: Wikipedia)
In class: read the story together on the screen and let the students vote at each choice point; on a second reading, try other choices to see different endings.