The Silver Below the Dam
Read the story: okuriko.com/read-story/the-silver-below-the-dam/
Answer the questions after reading the story. The questions are about the opening part that everyone reads, whatever they choose.
1. Reading Comprehension (5W1H)
-
1. Who? Who built the stone dam?
-
2. What? What does Ellie see when she leans over the bridge railing?
-
3. Where? Where do Ellie and Rosie wait to watch the fish?
-
4. When? When does Warden Ken say he will come back?
-
5. Why? Why does Ellie think the fish can't get over most of the dam?
-
6. How? How does one fish finally make it over the dam?
2. Vocabulary Matching
Match each word with its meaning. Write the letter of the meaning in the box next to the word.
- 1. cormorant
- 2. warden
- 3. trough
- 4. irrigation
- 5. sulky
- 6. bale
- a) A long, narrow, open container or channel that holds or carries water.
- b) A large, dark water bird with a long neck that dives underwater to catch fish.
- c) A big, tightly packed and tied bundle of hay or straw.
- d) Quietly grumpy and upset, showing you are cross without saying much.
- e) A person whose job is to look after a place, like the streams in this story, and make sure the rules are followed.
- f) Bringing water to fields through ditches, pipes or troughs so that crops can grow.
3. Think and Write
-
• At the first choice, did you have Ellie open a gap in Max's dam, or leave the dam alone and dig a side channel along the bank? Why did you pick that path?
-
• Max doesn't want anyone to touch his dam because he built it with his own hands. How would you feel if someone wanted to change something you had worked hard on? How would they need to ask for you to agree?
-
• Before trying anything, Ellie sits and watches the water for a long time to understand why the fish can't get through. What do you do when you want to find out why something isn't working?
-
• The children's swimming pond matters, and so does the fishes' journey. When what people need clashes with what animals need, what can be done to find a solution that is fair to everyone?
Activity
Line up a low wall of small stones across the middle of a deep tray, then pour water slowly from a cup and watch how it flows over the wall; next, tip one stone onto its side so more water pours through one spot. Drop a leaf or a cork into the water to find where the current is strongest, and draw what you see.
In this story, children help Ellie work out why pearl mullets heading upstream from Lake Van can't get over a knee-high stone dam. They watch the water closely, spot small differences and ask why when an idea fails, all while weighing the feelings of Max, who built the dam himself. Readers' choices decide which way Ellie tries.
Learning goals
- Learns that pearl mullets leave Lake Van every year and swim up the streams that flow into it to lay their eggs.
- Practices patient observation, noticing small differences such as thin and thick flowing water, and changing an idea and trying again when it doesn't work.
- Learns that even a low, human-made barrier can block the way for migrating fish.
- Thinks about how to find a shared solution while respecting someone else's hard work and listening to their worries.
Curriculum links: Science, Environmental education, Social studies. Values: Curiosity, Teamwork, Caring for nature.
Answer Key
- 1. Max, Rosie's big brother, built it.
- 2. Thousands of pearl mullets, all swimming the same way, with their backs glittering in the sun.
- 3. At the end of the dam by the bank, standing in shallow water that doesn't even reach their knees.
- 4. In three days, and if the fish still can't get through, he'll take the dam down.
- 5. The water flowing over it there is too thin for them to hold on.
- 6. It leaps up beside a mossy stone that has tipped onto its side, where the water pours out like a thick tongue.
Vocabulary matching: 1-b, 2-e, 3-a, 4-f, 5-d, 6-c
Fact Box
- Where does the pearl mullet live?
- The pearl mullet is found nowhere else in the world: it is endemic to the Lake Van basin in eastern Turkey. It thrives in the lake's salty, alkaline water, which other freshwater and sea fish cannot live in. (Source: Wikipedia)
- Why do pearl mullets swim up streams?
- They cannot lay their eggs in Lake Van's salty, soda-rich water, so from early April to the end of July large shoals move into the freshwater streams that flow into the lake. Once the stream water warms to about 13 °C, they swim upstream, lay their eggs on gravelly, sandy stretches where the current slows, and return to the lake. The young start heading down to the lake within one to two weeks of hatching. (Source: Van Provincial Directorate of Agriculture and Forestry)
- Can people catch pearl mullets during the migration?
- No. To protect the spawning fish, catching, keeping, selling or transporting pearl mullets is banned every year from 15 April to 15 July. People who break the ban are fined. (Source: Van Provincial Directorate of Agriculture and Forestry)
In class: read the story together on the screen and let the students vote at each choice point; on a second reading, try other choices to see different endings.